Sierra Club Files Appeal with DEP Over Proposed Cassville Surface Mine

The Sierra Club says its concerned about water quality issues for the New Hill West mine.

The State Journal
21 September 2010
By Mike Krafcik

MORGANTOWN -- The Sierra Club has filed an appeal to challenge the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection's water permit for the New Hill West mine in Cassville.

The notice was filed with the West Virginia Environmental Quality Control Board.

The permit was issued to the Patriot Mining Company for the 225-acre strip mine. The Sierra Club said the permit does not adequately control the water pollution that comes from this site.

Patriot Mining officials have indicated they would intend dump 1,000-10,000 tons of coal combustion waste per acre of mined area.

The club said the DEP standards fail to include any limits for toxic heavy metals that come from fly-ash and coal combustion bi-products.

The Sierra Club said the DEP is using out-dated testing procedures that will undermine the risks to ground water and streams from the ash disposal at mine sites.

"The DEP needs to have a pollution prevention plan in this permit that assures that any discharges from the mine will meet any water quality standards, they have not done that," said Jim Kotcon, of the Sierra Club West Virginia.

The Sierra Club's appeal will be heard as part of a evidentiary hearing before the Environmental Quality Board scheduled for November.